%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% % This Otter input file is for translating some problems % so that Larry Wos can work on them with Otter. The problems % are about associativity properties in the system LR (also R?). % % If you run this file through Otter, the sos list at % the end of the output file will contain 16 axioms, 2 % rules (CD and a rule for conjunction), and 16 big denials. % of the associativity properties, all in terms of the primitives % and in prefix. % % This has Bob Meyer's TSMALL/TBIG correction. op(800, infix, [->, &, v, o, +, <->]). op(700, prefix_assoc, ~). set(demod_inf). clear(demod_history). set(sos_queue). clear(for_sub). clear(back_sub). assign(max_given, 34). set(print_lists_at_end). list(sos). % This list contains axioms and rules for LR % Implication Axioms P(x -> x). % A1 Identity P((x -> y) -> ((z -> x) -> (z -> y))). % A2 Prefixing P((x -> y) -> ((y -> z) -> (x -> z))). % A3 Suffixing P((x -> (x -> y)) -> (x -> y)). % A4 Contraction P((x -> (y -> z)) -> (y -> (x -> z))). % A5 Contraction % Implication/Negation Axioms P(~ ~x -> x). % A6 Double Negation P((x -> ~x) -> ~x). % A7 Reductio P((x -> ~y) -> (y -> ~x)). % A8 Contraposition % Conjuction/Disjunction Axioms P((x & y) -> x). % A9 Simplification P((x & y) -> y). % A10 Simplification P(((x -> y) & (x -> z)) -> (x -> (y & z))). % A11 & Introduction P(x -> (x v y)). % A12 Addition P(y -> (x v y)). % A13 Addition P(((x -> z) & (y -> z)) -> ((x v y) -> z)). % A14 v Introduction % Axioms for Constants P(((TSMALL -> x) -> x) & (x -> (TSMALL -> x))). % A15 P(x -> TBIG). % A16 % Rules -P(x -> y) | -P(x) | P(y). % CD -P(x) | -P(y) | P(x & y). % Adjunction end_of_list. list(demodulators). % This list is used to rewrite clauses in list(sos). % The 16 operations in question. c1(x,y) = (x o ((x + x) o (y v ~y))). % C1 c2(x,y) = (x o (y v (~y v (~x o ~x)))). % C2 c3(x,y) = (x + (x o (~x o (y v ~y)))). % C3 c4(x,y) = (x v (x o (~x o (y v ~y)))). % C4 c5(x,y) = (x o ((x v ~x) o (y v ~y))). % C5 c6(x,y) = (x o (x v (~y v (~x o y)))). % C6 c7(x,y) = (x o (y v (~y v (~x o y)))). % C7 c8(x,y) = ((x + x) o (~y v (x o y))). % C8 c9(x,y) = (x o (x + (~x o (y v ~y)))). % C9 c10(x,y) = (x o (x v (~x o (y v ~y)))). % C10 c11(x,y) = (x v (x o (~y v (~x o y)))). % C11 c12(x,y) = (x o (~y v (x + (~x o y)))). % C12 c13(x,y) = (x o (~y v (y o (x v ~x)))). % C13 c14(x,y) = (x o (~y v (y + (~x o y)))). % C14 c15(x,y) = (x o (~y v (y o (~x v y)))). % C15 c16(x,y) = ((x v (x o ~x)) o (y v ~y)). % C16 % Definitions of fusion and fission. (x o y) = ~(x -> ~y). (x + y) = (~x -> y). (x <-> y) = ((x -> y) & (y -> x)). % Rewrite the operations into prefix. (x -> y) = i(x,y). (~x) = n(x). (x & y) = and(x,y). (x v y) = or(x,y). end_of_list. list(sos). % Here are the denials of the associativity properties for C1 -- C16. % I guess the challenge is to prove these in LR. -P(c1(c1(a,b),c) <-> c1(a,c1(b,c))) | $Ans(C1). -P(c2(c2(a,b),c) <-> c2(a,c2(b,c))) | $Ans(C2). -P(c3(c3(a,b),c) <-> c3(a,c3(b,c))) | $Ans(C3). -P(c4(c4(a,b),c) <-> c4(a,c4(b,c))) | $Ans(C4). -P(c5(c5(a,b),c) <-> c5(a,c5(b,c))) | $Ans(C5). -P(c6(c6(a,b),c) <-> c6(a,c6(b,c))) | $Ans(C6). -P(c7(c7(a,b),c) <-> c7(a,c7(b,c))) | $Ans(C7). -P(c8(c8(a,b),c) <-> c8(a,c8(b,c))) | $Ans(C8). -P(c9(c9(a,b),c) <-> c9(a,c9(b,c))) | $Ans(C9). -P(c10(c10(a,b),c) <-> c10(a,c10(b,c))) | $Ans(C10). -P(c11(c11(a,b),c) <-> c11(a,c11(b,c))) | $Ans(C11). -P(c12(c12(a,b),c) <-> c12(a,c12(b,c))) | $Ans(C12). -P(c13(c13(a,b),c) <-> c13(a,c13(b,c))) | $Ans(C13). -P(c14(c14(a,b),c) <-> c14(a,c14(b,c))) | $Ans(C14). -P(c15(c15(a,b),c) <-> c15(a,c15(b,c))) | $Ans(C15). -P(c16(c16(a,b),c) <-> c16(a,c16(b,c))) | $Ans(C16). end_of_list. %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% % Here is a second input file, constructed from the output of the % preceding input file. % % This might be the set of problems that Bob Meyer was thinking of % for Larry Wos to try. set(hyper_res). set(order_history). clear(print_kept). clear(back_sub). assign(pick_given_ratio, 4). list(usable). -P(i(x,y)) | -P(x) | P(y). % Condensed Detachment -P(x) | -P(y) | P(and(x,y)). % Adjunction end_of_list. list(sos). P(i(x,x)). % A1 Identity P(i(i(x,y),i(i(z,x),i(z,y)))). % A2 Prefixing P(i(i(x,y),i(i(y,z),i(x,z)))). % A3 Suffixing P(i(i(x,i(x,y)),i(x,y))). % A4 Contraction P(i(i(x,i(y,z)),i(y,i(x,z)))). % A5 Contraction P(i(n(n(x)),x)). % A6 Double Negation P(i(i(x,n(x)),n(x))). % A7 Reductio P(i(i(x,n(y)),i(y,n(x)))). % A8 Contraposition P(i(and(x,y),x)). % A9 Simplification P(i(and(x,y),y)). % A10 Simplification P(i(and(i(x,y),i(x,z)),i(x,and(y,z)))). % A11 & Introduction P(i(x,or(x,y))). % A12 Addition P(i(x,or(y,x))). % A13 Addition P(i(and(i(x,y),i(z,y)),i(or(x,z),y))). % A14 v Introduction P(and(i(i(TSMALL,x),x),i(x,i(TSMALL,x)))). % A15 P(i(x,TBIG)). % A16 end_of_list. list(passive). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(i(n(n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(i(b,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(n(i(b,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(i(b,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(n(i(b,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(i(n(n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C1). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a))))))))),n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a)))))))))),n(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a)))))))))))))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(n(b))))))))),or(n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(a)))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(n(b))))))))),or(n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(a))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a))))))))),n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a)))))))))),n(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(n(a))))))))))))))))))))) | $Ans(C2). -P(and(i(i(n(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(n(i(n(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(i(n(b),n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(i(n(b),n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))))),i(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(i(n(b),n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(i(n(b),n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(n(i(n(i(n(a),n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))) | $Ans(C3). -P(and(i(or(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(n(i(n(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))))),i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))))),or(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(n(i(n(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))) | $Ans(C4). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(or(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(n(i(b,n(n(i(or(b,n(b)),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(n(i(b,n(n(i(or(b,n(b)),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(n(i(b,n(n(i(or(b,n(b)),n(or(c,n(c)))))))),n(n(i(b,n(n(i(or(b,n(b)),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(or(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))),n(n(i(a,n(n(i(or(a,n(a)),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C5). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(n(i(b,n(or(b,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(b,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(n(i(b,n(or(b,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(b,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(a,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C6). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))),or(n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))),or(n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(c,or(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(b,or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C7). -P(and(i(n(i(i(n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b)))))))),n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b))))))),n(c))))))),n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(n(c),n(i(b,n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(n(c),n(i(b,n(c))))))))))))))),i(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(n(c),n(i(b,n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(n(i(i(n(b),b),n(or(n(c),n(i(b,n(c)))))))))))))),n(i(i(n(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b)))))))),n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(n(i(i(n(a),a),n(or(n(b),n(i(a,n(b))))))),n(c)))))))))) | $Ans(C8). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(n(i(b,n(i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(n(i(b,n(i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(n(i(b,n(i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(n(i(b,n(i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))) | $Ans(C9). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(n(i(b,n(or(b,n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(n(i(b,n(or(b,n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(n(i(b,n(or(b,n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c))))))))),n(n(i(b,n(or(b,n(i(n(b),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(a,n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))))) | $Ans(C10). -P(and(i(or(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(n(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c)))))))),or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(or(b,n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))))))))))),i(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(or(b,n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(or(b,n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))))))))))),or(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(n(or(a,n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C11). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(b),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(a),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C12). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a))))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a))))))))),n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a)))))))))))))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(a,n(a)))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(i(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(b,n(b))))))))),n(or(a,n(a))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a))))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a))))))))),n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(a,n(a))))))))))))))))))))) | $Ans(C13). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c)))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),i(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),i(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c))))))))),n(i(n(a),n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(b),n(c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b)))))))),n(or(n(c),i(n(c),n(i(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),i(n(b),n(i(n(a),n(b))))))))),n(c))))))))))) | $Ans(C14). -P(and(i(n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(n(a),b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(n(a),b))))))))),c)))))))),n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c))))))))),n(i(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c)))))))),n(or(n(a),n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c))))))))))))))))),i(n(i(a,n(or(n(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c))))))))),n(i(n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c)))))))),n(or(n(a),n(i(b,n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(b),c)))))))))))))))),n(i(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(n(a),b)))))))),n(or(n(c),n(i(c,n(or(n(n(i(a,n(or(n(b),n(i(b,n(or(n(a),b))))))))),c))))))))))) | $Ans(C15). -P(and(i(n(i(or(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b))))),n(i(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b))))),n(n(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c))))),n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(n(i(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(b))))),n(or(c,n(c))))),n(n(i(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(b))))),n(or(c,n(c))))))))))),i(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(n(i(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(b))))),n(or(c,n(c))))),n(n(i(or(b,n(i(b,n(n(b))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))))),n(i(or(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b))))),n(i(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b))))),n(n(n(i(or(a,n(i(a,n(n(a))))),n(or(b,n(b)))))))))),n(or(c,n(c)))))))) | $Ans(C16). end_of_list.